
File photo of a Rapid Metro train seen entering the Railway Station at Gurugram in Haryana.
Over 60,000 commuters keep their fingers crossed as RMGL takes on HSVP over operations of the Gurugram metro project in the Punjab and Haryana High Court tomorrow
Sachin Sharma, 43, regularly commutes to his workplace at Cyber City in the Rapid Metro. He has been boarding the train at Sector 54 Chowk metro station and alighting at IndusInd Bank Cyber City as a daily routine for the past one year. But he is a worried man now with uncertainty looming large over the continuity of the network.
For a city with an abysmal record on public transport, the news of Rapid Metro network struggling financially has come as rude shock for the residents. Around 60,000 people commute daily in Rapid Metro, India’s first fully privately financed metro system that also acts as a feeder to the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) network, connecting at the Sikanderpur metro station on the Yellow Line.
On shaky ground
Not able to meet its targeted ridership of one lakh — for the first and second phases put together — the almost 12-km-long metro network has been on shaky ground financially since it began its commercial operations on November 14, 2013. The first signs of trouble appeared last year when Rapid MetroRail Gurgaon Limited (RMGL) accused the Haryana Shehri Vikas Pradhikaran (HSVP), formerly Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA), of material breaches and defaults on the concession contract and asked the Haryana government to fix them within 90 days.
In an agreement reached between the RMGL and HSVP (then HUDA) on December 9, 2009, the company was entitled to participate in property development and advertisement at project site to generate revenue in addition to the fare. As per the contract, the concessionaire has the rights to display visual advertisements inside the rolling stock, the stations or along the route. The company was also allowed to utilizethe land over, under and within the stations for property development and commercial exploitation during the concession period, subject to a limit of 250 square metre per station.
Non-fare revenue
Passenger fare contributes only 30%-40% to the total revenue of a metro project, depending upon which stage it is in; the rest is the non-fare revenue generated through advertisements and property rights. It is these rights that are the bone of contention between the two partners, with the RMGL accusing the HSVP of not allowing them in full, as per the contract.
Sources privy to the dispute between the two told The Hindu that the company also accused HSVP of failing to carry out the development work along the metro corridor as per the Master Plan-2031 and not putting in place a sound feeder bus mechanism, hitting the ridership and causing loss of fare revenue.
The HSVP has rubbished the charges saying the company is levelling false allegations as it is looking for an easy way out of the financial mess it is in because of its own reasons. It has also accused the RMGL of failing to meet its obligations on ridership.
‘Poor management’
Industry experts partially blame the financial troubles of the Rapid Metro on the poor management of the project and bad marketing strategies. The fact that the first Managing Director of RMGL, Sanjiv Rai, was denied an extension and was replaced by Rajiv Banga was enough hint at his “non-satisfactory performance”. It was in sharp contrast to four extensions to ‘Metro Man’ E. Sreedharan before he retired in 2011, and four-year extension to DMRC MD Mangu Singh, said experts.
On the marketing front too, while the RMGL seemed to be wasting its efforts on wrong choices such as running birthday trains to earn revenue, it failed to attract the larger workforce in the Cyber City to use the network. Experts said that tie-ups with companies operating in the Cyber City and lucrative offers to their employees could have helped the RMGL achieve its targetted ridership, especially when the corridor was connected to the DMRC’s Yellow Line.
Extending the RMGL network along the Golf Course Road, the most elite address in the Millennium City, especially when the stretch was being widened to 16-lane highway, for its Phase-II too proved to be an unwise decision. Instead, connecting the Udyog Vihar Industrial Area, housing a large number of garment units and other companies, with the network and extending it further to the Maruti Suzuki plant on Old Delhi-Gurugram Road and bus stand could have added far more numbers to the ridership. In the future, the extension towards Udyog Vihar could also act as a possible link between the DMRC’s Yellow and Blue Lines, further augmenting the ridership.
Financial troubles
The financial troubles of IL&FS, the company that constructed the Rapid Metro, in mid-2018 and the Union government moving an application before the National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai, seeking suspension of its board of directors on the grounds of massive mismanagement of public funds proved to be the last nail in the coffin of the RMGL.
The RMGL was among the 38 domestic group entities of IL&FS classified as “Red Entity” by the Union government, saying that it could not meet its payment obligations towards even senior secured financial creditors.
The HSVP has said that there is a need for due diligence on the financial activities of the Rapid Metro. The authority officials maintain that nobody knows who the Rapid Metro management had borrowed money from and where they spent it and what fraudulent contracts they signed.
“When a private party comes to develop an infrastructure within the city limits it has to face many challenges and the support of the government is the first thing which is solicited. When a project like this fails for whatsoever reasons, it demotivates private players, investors and even the government. The need of the hour is to get all the associated parties on a common platform so that they are able to play their respective roles and ensure that the project runs smoothly,” said Sarvesh Tiwari, an infrastructure expert who was earlier associated with the Rapid Metro project.
While the two parties battle it out legally in the Punjab and Haryana High Court — the matter is scheduled for hearing on September 17 — the commuters, the most important stakeholder in the matter, keep their fingers crossed for a favourable outcome.
78 thoughts on “Rapid Metro losing steam?”
levofloxacin 250mg oral purchase levaquin online cheap
avodart sale cost zofran 8mg ondansetron brand
suhagra 100mg brand aurogra 100mg usa order generic estrace
generic lamotrigine 200mg order minipress 2mg retin gel oral
order tadalafil 20mg online cheap voltaren usa voltaren 50mg brand
accutane 10mg cost accutane sale azithromycin 500mg ca
indomethacin 75mg cheap buy lamisil 250mg without prescription purchase trimox pills
brand tadalafil 20mg ed medications over the counter viagra online
brand arimidex 1mg viagra questions and answers canadian viagra online pharmacy
generique tadalafil 5mg viagra comprimГ© viagra 25mg comprimГ©
cialis 20mg kaufen generika cialis 20mg für männer sildenafil 100mg ohne rezept
buy isotretinoin pills stromectol oral ivermectin 200
purchase provigil generic buy diamox 250 mg generic diamox 250 mg pills
brand doxycycline 100mg purchase vardenafil furosemide 100mg for sale
order altace online avapro 300mg us azelastine brand
clonidine 0.1mg cheap order antivert online spiriva 9 mcg us
order buspirone 10mg generic ditropan 5mg cost order ditropan generic
order hytrin 5mg buy azulfidine 500 mg buy azulfidine pills
order alendronate online cheap pepcid 40mg cheap purchase pepcid online
order benicar 20mg generic buy acetazolamide 250mg generic buy diamox 250 mg generic
purchase prograf labetalol price urso 150mg tablet
cost imdur 40mg order generic micardis order telmisartan 80mg pill
purchase zyban pills purchase cetirizine sale quetiapine order
order molnunat 200mg buy naproxen order lansoprazole sale
zoloft 50mg over the counter Pfizer viagra sildenafil 100mg usa
imuran price generic salbutamol viagra price
cialis savings card Buy cialis low price buy sildenafil 100mg pills
buy cialis 40mg online cheap tadalafil order online order amantadine 100 mg without prescription
order revia online cheap buy naltrexone for sale brand aripiprazole
order dapsone 100mg generic buy aceon 4mg for sale perindopril 8mg drug
provera 10mg cost cyproheptadine 4 mg uk order periactin pills
purchase modafinil without prescription modafinil 100mg uk ivermectin human
buy fluvoxamine without prescription order luvox 100mg without prescription glipizide ca
accutane cost buy deltasone online cheap buy prednisone 10mg online
generic nootropil 800mg sildenafil overnight shipping usa sildenafil pills 100mg
cheap zithromax 250mg prednisolone 20mg tablet neurontin over the counter
cialis 10mg ca buy sildenafil 100mg for sale cheap viagra 50mg
furosemide price buy doxycycline online cheap buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg pills
cost tadalafil tadalafil 40mg us order anafranil 50mg
chloroquine 250mg sale olumiant online buy baricitinib 4mg price
purchase itraconazole sale buy progesterone 100mg buy tinidazole 500mg without prescription
metformin for sale cost lipitor 20mg buy tadalafil tablets
order zyprexa without prescription nebivolol 20mg usa diovan usa
norvasc 10mg over the counter female cialis cvs cialis 20mg uk
buy clozaril 50mg online cheap order combivent generic order decadron 0,5 mg sale
viagra medication lisinopril 2.5mg over the counter lisinopril 10mg over the counter
linezolid 600mg pills zyvox 600mg sale doubleu casino
purchase prilosec online cheap casino slots gambling best online casino games
lopressor 100mg generic cost tenormin 100mg cheap vardenafil 10mg
order essays online academia writing play slots
levitra over the counter purchase pregabalin generic methylprednisolone 16mg online
write my paper for me buying an essay sildenafil 100mg pills for sale
order clomiphene 100mg online purchase ventolin inhalator generic online casino no deposit bonus
cialis 40mg us buy tadalafil 10mg online cheap sildenafil overnight delivery
triamcinolone 10mg for sale triamcinolone 4mg usa desloratadine for sale
order dapoxetine 30mg generic dapoxetine oral buy synthroid 75mcg pill
tadalafil usa tadalafil 10mg us viagra mail order us
purchase orlistat generic orlistat 120mg brand zovirax 400mg ca
cialis 5 mg order inderal generic plavix 75mg pill
zyloprim 100mg ca order crestor 10mg generic ezetimibe sale
methotrexate us metoclopramide 10mg cost order metoclopramide 20mg
order motilium 10mg pill tetracycline 250mg generic buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg online cheap
cozaar sale order generic topiramate 200mg oral topamax 100mg
buy baclofen 10mg pills buy generic zanaflex cost ketorolac
imitrex 50mg tablet imitrex for sale dutasteride pills
order colchicine online cheap play roulette recommended you read
ranitidine 300mg brand order celecoxib for sale order celecoxib 100mg pills
play roulette for free casino near me wind creek casino online play
tamsulosin order flomax 0.4mg pill buy aldactone 25mg pill
overnight cialis delivery acillin sale cipro buy online
buy zocor generic buy proscar 1mg online generic proscar
buy metronidazole 400mg without prescription buy flagyl online bactrim 480mg for sale
keflex brand buy erythromycin 250mg sale erythromycin 500mg pills
cialis for sales order generic tadalafil sildenafil 100mg ca
sildenafil over counter buy viagra 50mg for sale order cialis 20mg sale
ceftin sale order methocarbamol online cheap robaxin for sale online
buy trazodone 100mg generic buy suhagra pill buy aurogra 100mg generic
buy essay service stromectol 12mg generic ivermectin 3 mg pills